Q3 Workforce Index reveals sustained recruiting, turnover challenges in restaurants

Ron Ruggless | Oct 22, 2018  Nations Restaurant News

Recruiting remains a challenge for restaurants, and the third-quarter People Report Workforce Index registers how wide and deep the difficulty is.

“We’ve seen sustained levels for the past two or three years that we hadn’t seen in a decade or more,” said Michael Harms, vice president of operations at Dallas-based TDn2K, which produces the People Report Workforce Index quarterly.

“The percentage of companies reporting difficulty is high,” Harms said. “People are saying it’s almost impossible to staff a restaurant these days.”

The national unemployment rate fell to 3.7 percent in September, the lowest level since 1969, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Meanwhile, the gross domestic product continued to rise from its 4.1 percent growth in the second quarter.

“The demand for workers sparked by this economic growth and low unemployment has resulted in a shortage of quality employees and record high turnover rates as workers are presented with more employment opportunities,” the third-quarter Workforce Index noted. “Barring a change to the macroeconomic environment, labor pressures are expected to remain high with increasing wage pressures posing an added complication.”

Harms said the People Report spent the past year revising the Workforce Index, which started in 2006 and measures expected market pressure on restaurant employment and is based on surveys of restaurant industry human resources departments and recruiters.

The Workforce Index now has a baseline value of 0 and ranges from -100 to +100. Values over 0 indicate increased levels of that component, and the strength of each value is measured by its distance from 0. An overall index value is calculated as a weighted average of the five components, including employment levels, recruiting difficulty, job vacancies, employment expectation and turnover.

For the third quarter ended Sept. 30, the overall Workforce Index registered a value of +26.9, indicating moderate increases in labor pressure.

Recruiting pressure seems to be highest in the quick-service segment, Harm said.

“They really are struggling to find staff,” Harms said. “It’s across the industry, but we really are seeing the struggle in QSR.”

At the hourly level, the turnover comparison remains significant across the segments, he said. It’s significant across most segments.

“Casual dining and upscale fine dining scored a little lower in the quarter,” Harm said. “Casual dining is in a tough spot. When it comes to competition, they are taking fire from upscale; they are taking fire from fast casual. They are surrounded by two of the industry darlings, and we’re seeing that in the demand for employees.”

Overall, Harms added, it remains difficult to find employees for all segments of the restaurant industry, a trend that has continued since post-recession labor pressures began about five years ago.

“Those challenges don’t seem to be going away any time soon,” he said. “This is the longest period of sustained labor pressures we have tracked.”

Back

What Clients Say About Patrice & Associates

  • Hospitality Recruiter Helps Find Me a Job!

    Chris Giles was very helpful throughout this whole process. First he helped me get my resume polished to send off, he was very patient with me during this. I was very busy with my job search and interviews, but he always made sure to follow up if I didn't get something back to him and was always patient with me. Once we had my resume updated he got it sent off and set up my interviews, he was very helpful in coaching me and making sure I was prepared for the interview. Chris was always there to answer any questions I had and touched base frequently as we were waiting to hear back about things certain things. If I hadn't heard back from one of the hiring departments he would contact them and I would hear from them later that day. Now after getting hired and starting the training program he checks in with me weekly to see how things are going and provides a listening ear if I need to vent about anything. He has been very encouraging and has helped me be more confident going through this hiring  process. Thank you Chris!   Charissa Hahn     Have a Hospitality Recruitment Specialist work for you for FREE Hospitality Recruiter Helps Find Me a Job!
  • I would like to thank Frank Rondeau for leading me through all the steps required to land  a great job opportunity. Frank took the time to ask questions about my career goals and personal plans to create a personal resume, based on my career and work experience, in order to connect me with a great job fit for myself- and for my future employer. The end result was getting my interview process handled, and giving me appropriate advice on how to handle the interview for it to be successful... and it sure was. Thank you Frank and Patrice and Associates for helping me get started on this exciting next chapter of my life! -Elaine Garcia   Started on this exciting next chapter of my life!
  • Hospitality Recruiter Can Help You Find a Job!

    Karl was the best asset in securing my new position. He was there coaching and teaching me every step of the way. I have been working in the food industry for 20+ years and this is the first time I have used a recruiter. I have been on both ends of the hiring process and Karl has helped to know what people are looking for and what I should be looking for when hiring new employees. I look forward to meeting Karl and shaking his hand. If needed I would seek Karl out again!         Mahmoud Elkhyati         Need help with your resume – Have a Recruitment Specialist help you for FREE       Hospitality Recruiter Can Help You Find a Job!
  • Hospitality Recruitment Works!

    My interactions with Mr. Richard were professional. He was very accommodating to my wants in needs when it came to the company I was looking to become a part of. I had tried myself to obtain a position with this company, but I was not able to do so on my own. With Richard's help I was able to land the position.  He kept me in the loop when it came to every interview that I had from beginning to end and kept me very upbeat and positive about the experience. I believe this is how a head hunter or recruiter should perform when dealing with clients very professional and had integrity in everything that he did.     Albert Jones     Hospitality Recruitment matches YOUR skills with the perfect job Hospitality Recruitment Works!
  • Hospitality Recruiters Are Here to Help

    Daniel was a great help to me on my job search. From the first time I was contacted by him I felt he was here not only to help the company find the right candidate but he was there to make sure I was right for the position.  Daniel is very persistent when he is working with you.  He knows that time is of the essence and he helps you adhere to a very strict timeline to be successful.  Daniel is there for you when you are feeling unsure and is always available to discuss just about anything.  He has a wealth of FOH & BOH knowledge and that really put me at ease because I have not met many recruiters with FOH & BOH experience. Talking to someone who has been where you have been really puts you at ease!  I am very appreciative that I had the chance to work with Daniel on this occasion.  I am thankful he was understanding, attentive, communicative, and seems to generally care about you as a person and a perspective candidate! Katherine Woods         Career Coaches that help you for FREE Hospitality Recruiters Are Here to Help